Mobile Blog Overview Mobile Blog Overview

What Can My Lawyer Do if My Doctor or Hospital Disputes My Medical Malpractice Claim?

February 24, 2025

Do You Have a Case?

Find Out Now >

Disputes in medical malpractice cases can feel overwhelming, especially when a trusted doctor or hospital denies responsibility for your injuries. For many patients, this is more than a legal battle; it’s a fight for accountability and fairness.

With $60 billion spent annually on malpractice claims, healthcare providers and insurers often prioritize their bottom line over the well-being of those harmed. Denied claims and minimized payouts leave many patients struggling against a complex, frustrating system on their own.

If your claim has been rejected, a skilled Cleveland medical malpractice lawyer can stand by your side, challenge unfair denials, and build a solid case for justice. Discover how Nurenberg, Paris, Heller & McCarthy can fight for your rights and help you recover the compensation you deserve.

What Happens When Doctors or Hospitals Deny Liability?

Medical malpractice claims are more common than you might think: One in three clinicians face lawsuits during their careers. When doctors or hospitals deny responsibility, they often have powerful insurance companies and legal teams working to protect their interests. These entities frequently minimize claims by disputing evidence or shifting blame to avoid paying fair compensation.

This creates a difficult situation for patients. Proving negligence can be challenging, especially when going up against large hospitals backed by extensive resources and legal defenses.

Partnering with an experienced Cleveland medical malpractice attorney can make a difference. They can gather critical evidence, challenge unfair denials, and fight for the compensation you deserve, ensuring you’re not left to face the system alone.

How Does a Lawyer Build a Strong Medical Malpractice Case?

Building a solid medical malpractice case requires both legal knowledge and medical insight. An experienced legal team brings resources and strategies far beyond what patients can access alone, offering crucial support to effectively challenge healthcare providers and their insurers.

Here’s how a skilled legal team bolsters claims and addresses disputed cases:

  • Thorough Investigation: Attorneys gather key evidence, including medical records, treatment logs, and diagnostic test results. They carefully review surgical notes for missed protocols and scrutinize medication records to identify errors that may have led to harm.
  • Consulting Medical Experts: Attorneys collaborate with medical experts to assess the case and identify instances of negligence. These experts can explain how errors, such as delayed treatment or a missed diagnosis, contributed to complications, helping to strengthen the claim during negotiations or in court.
  • Depositions and Witness Testimonies: Attorneys question medical staff under oath to uncover key details about the care provided. They challenge surgeons on deviations from standard practices and call nurses or technicians as witnesses to reveal potential lapses or oversights.
  • Countering the Defense’s Arguments: Defense teams often try to shift blame by citing pre-existing conditions or unrelated factors. Attorneys counter these tactics with detailed timelines, medical records, and expert testimony, clearly showing how provider negligence caused the injury.

Physicians prevail in nearly 90% of trial cases with weak negligence evidence but only about 50% of trial cases when strong proof is presented. Partnering with a skilled medical malpractice law firm can help you gather solid evidence, boosting your chances of a successful outcome.

Can My Lawyer Help Me Resolve a Dispute Without Going to Trial?

The majority of medical malpractice cases never go to trial. About 97% are resolved through settlements, while only 3% are heard by a jury. Experienced attorneys often use alternative dispute resolution methods to settle claims, helping victims avoid the time, stress, and uncertainty of a drawn-out trial.

Common resolution methods include:

  • Negotiations With Insurers: Lawyers are skilled negotiators who know how to handle insurance companies. They can push back against low settlement offers and use evidence to justify the compensation you deserve.
  • Mediation and Arbitration: Some disputes are resolved through mediation or arbitration. These processes allow both parties to present their cases in a less formal setting than a courtroom. A lawyer presents your side and ensures any agreements are fair and binding.
  • Preparing for Trial: If a fair settlement cannot be reached outside of court, your attorney will prepare your case for trial. This involves drafting legal arguments, presenting evidence, and cross-examining witnesses to advocate for your rights before a judge or jury.

Let Nurenberg, Paris, Heller & McCarthy Fight for You After a Denied Claim

Medical malpractice claims often become difficult to resolve due to resistance from doctors, hospitals, and insurers. The knowledgeable team at Nurenberg, Paris, Heller & McCarthy provides the support needed to hold negligent providers accountable.

We handle a wide range of medical malpractice cases, including surgical errors, delayed diagnoses, and birth injuries. Our results include an $8.5 million award for birth trauma and $4 million for failure to treat, reflecting our commitment to achieving justice for our clients.

Get the legal representation you deserve. Contact our attorneys today for a free consultation to discuss your case.

Related Posts